By Andy Delaney
This entry order issued November 2, and I could probably just link Meghan Trainor's song and the meme to your left and call it a day. But I won't. Mostly.
Plaintiff sued the State on five counts. The civil division dismissed one count early and the rest on March 25, 2026. In May, plaintiff appealed the dismissal of Counts 2 through 4 only. That appeal is still pending. In September, plaintiff filed a second notice of appeal—this time from the March 25 order as to Count 1. His theory: the civil division never entered judgment on a separate document, so under the 150-day rule judgment wasn't "entered" until August, his Rule 60(b) motion tolled the appeal clock, and his September notice was timely.
SCOV dismissed the appeal as untimely, denied reconsideration, and now denies plaintiff's motion to vacate the denial of reconsideration. (Yes, really.) Because the reconsideration ruling decided questions of law, SCOV publishes it.
The short version: two strikes. First, even assuming the 150-day rule applies, plaintiff waived it by filing his first notice of appeal in May. The separate-document requirement exists only to pin down when the appeal clock starts, and a party who appeals anyway has shown he knows the judgment is final. Second, you get one appeal per final judgment. Plaintiff is trying to challenge a different piece of the same order he already appealed. No.
Maynus v. State, 2026 VT 50 (mem.).
Comments
Post a Comment